Overview
What is NexaAI?
NexaAI is an AI tools aggregator.
It provides a platform to facilitate:
- AI users who tries to find their next AI tool
- AI tool creators to market their newly created tool
The problem
Through web analytics tool, we discovered that the dropout rate of the new AI tool submissions flow is very high compared to site and industry average.
Impact
User experience impact
+86%
in completion rate compared to the pre-redesign version.
-35%
in time spent to complete the flow.
Business impact
+22%
in new tools submissions.
-32%
in engineering hours required for scraping and processing new AI tool data.
Discovery: interview
We identified high-dropout rate but lacked clarity on its causes. To gain deeper insights, we conducted interviews with AI tool creators to understand their experience with the submission process and uncover potential pain points.
1. Recruitment
Five interviewees recruited from existing users who successfully submitted at least 1 new AI tool.
2. Process
- 25 mins remote video conference sessions
- five initial interview questions + probing
3. Insights
Used affinity diagram to distill insights.
Research insights
1. Time consuming
The AI tool creators found the form relatively long and noted that fields requiring marketing materials or financial commitments added extra effort. This often led users to pause the process, sometimes forgetting to return.
2. Confusing requirements
Users struggled to distinguish certain fields, like "feature highlights" vs. "use cases," leading to uncertainty and form abandonment.
Design challenge
HWM Statement
How might we help tool creators save time and gain greater clarity when submitting their new AI tool?
Challenge 1
"save time"
Solution 1
Streamline the process
We can streamline the form by re-organizing the form elements based on their importance.
Challenge 2
"gain greater clarity"
Solution 2
Offer more assistance to confusing fields
We can provide more useful information to clarify the requirements and purpose of the fields.
Let's take a closer look at how I translate these solutions into real design.
Solution 1: Streamline the process
Reduce submission time and cognitive load through strategic prioritization.
A deeper look into the problem
After identifying these key friction points - particularly the cognitive load from complex form fields and the premature financial decisions - we decided to tackle the root cause through information architecture redesign.
Redesign the information architecture
After discussing with our product manager, we prioritized all form elements into four levels of importance. I then re-organized these elements based on their priority.
Please refer to the details below for a comprehensive list of changes.
1. Ensure important element to be completed first
With Priority 0 (P0) elements established, we decided to place them on the first page of the form. For users who are not logged in, the first page prompts them to log in or sign up. Being logged in allows us to pre-fill some of the creator's information, reducing the effort required for submission.
Logged-in users can proceed directly to enter tool's basic info.
2. Streamline the submission flow by making promotion a standalone feature
We decided to move the paid promotion elements out of the submission flow because, as a financial commitment, lingering on this step could discourage users from completing their tool submissions. Instead, we relocated these elements to the account management page, where we have more space to showcase what the paid promotion entails.
3. Reduce form complexity while preserving optional fields
Since some of the Priority 2 & 3 elements, such as creator's Linkedin link and Tool gallery, are less important and requires more preparation time, we decided to place them in a second-level menu, accessible via a accordion link. This allows users who wish to promote themselves to fill in these fields, while others can save time by skipping them.
4. Reduce form redundancy
5. Flexible submission timeline
We reduced the save progress functionality to give users the freedom to complete their submission at their own pace. Now when users encounter fields that require preparation time, such as demo videos or media gallery, they can save their progress and return later when ready.
Solution 2: Offer assistance
To reduce confusion around certain fields, we implemented various forms of assistance to guide users and help them complete the form smoothly.
A deeper look into the problem
Through our previous interviews, we discovered that most of the confusion occurs when users fill out the additional information for their new AI tool on page 2.
Design goals
Based on previous interviews and user needs, we identified two key goals for effective assistance.
1. Clarity & Guidance
Ensure each form field clearly conveys its intent, helping users understand what information is needed and why it's important.
2. User confidence
Demonstrate how certain fields will display, reducing uncertainty and improving confidence during the process.
Proposals
Through brainstorming, I identified two ways of offering assistance.
Stakeholders evaluation
We carried out stakeholders discussions for the two plans.
Text specifications provide the best tradeoff by offering constant guidance without requiring extra interaction. They remain visible, ensuring clarity while maintaining usability across devices. But some also favored image preview because they provide clear, detailed explanations, often paired with images to make complex fields easier to understand.
In that case, we decided to combine both approaches. For simpler fields, we’ll use text specifications for quick and easy guidance. For more complex fields, like “gallery,” we’ll use image preview. Instead of an icon for tooltips, we’ll use a text link such as “What is this?” that shows a rich media hint when hovered or tapped. This approach makes it easier to tap on mobile and more accessible for screen readers.
Validation: Usability testing and follow-up interviews
After finalizing the direction with approach #2, I proceeded to design the high-fidelity version and conducted a usability test.
1. Preparation
- Task instruction: “You created a new AI tool and you want it to be on NexaAI.”
- 10 participants recruited from existing users who already submitted at least 1 tool.
2. Process
- 45 mins remote sessions
- Participants were asked to think out loud while completing the task
- Short interviews after the task is completed
3. Insights
We analyzed the usability results and the feedbacks collected from interview.
Findings & Final iteration
The general consensus from usability testing and interviews was positive, with only a few minor adjustments needed to improve the overall experience.
Users were confused with the preview
During user testing, while the majority of users successfully navigated the submission process, a few participants mentioned that the abstract nature of the previews made it difficult to envision their tool's final presentation.
Final designs
Takeaways
Form design
I saw firsthand how form design complexity goes beyond aesthetics - layout, reading flow, and cognitive load all significantly impact usability, especially on desktop.
Be careful with trends
The original progress tracker design was inspired by multiple competitors. A common trend is to allocate half the screen for relevant content while the other half contains interactive elements. However, this approach proved to be less space-efficient.